Did Nemechek Play Fair in Canadian Win?

Did Nemechek Play Fair in Canadian Win?
What do you think of the Custer-Nemechek finish at the Canadian Tires Motorsports Park on Sept. 4? (Images from video captures)


JR Motorsports driver Cole Custer was the class of the field in his number 00 Chevy Silverado all weekend at Canadian Tire Motorsport Park. Custer led a race high 39 out of the 66 laps raced, while Nemechek led 19 laps. Custer had the overtime race sewn up going into the final turn before the checkered flag. However, Nemechek, in the Nemco Motorsports number 8, put and held Custer in the wall until they passed the Start-Finish line with Nemechek in the lead by the length of his truck’s engine compartment.


How It Unfolded

Did Nemechek Play Fair in Canadian Win?
Custer has a lead going into Turn 18B.


Custer was on his way to a win and a Truck Series Chase berth. Although Nemechek was back there nearing his bumper, Custer was secure in first place – as long as everybody drove clean. Nemechek, with one win already and locked into the Chase, didn’t. This was a must-win race for the JRM driver to get a spot in the Chase.


Did Nemechek Play Fair in Canadian Win?
At the apex of Turn 18C, the final turn or the race, Nemechek bumps Custer, turning him towards the outside wall.


At first, the incident just looked like racing. Nemechek even said it after the race: “Rubbin’ is racin’,” which is something you’ll hear almost every commentator say at least once during a race broadcast. However, if you watch the video of the incident, you can see Custer recovering his lost truck as he climbs the track a bit.


Did Nemechek Play Fair in Canadian Win?
In this screenshot, you can see that Nemechek is clear of Custer and in the groove exiting Turn 18C.


You then see Nemechek take a hard left and push Custer off the track and then into the wall. You can also see his wheels turned into Custer’s truck, keeping him in the grass and against the wall, ensuring his own victory.



A number of years ago, something like this was an almost regular occurrence. Drivers got put into the wall quite often. However, in my 30-plus years of watching NASCAR racing, I can count on the fingers of one hand the times where someone put another driver into the wall and then turned into that driver to keep him against the wall.


Did Nemechek Play Fair in Canadian Win?
You can see Nemechek has followed Custer up the track and almost completely out of the groove, although he was completely clear and didn’t need to.


This incident was nothing but Nemechek wanting the win and the bonus points that come from it, and knowing that he didn’t have the truck to race cleanly and get that win. He knew that he had to play dirty in order to pass Custer. So, he did.


Did Nemechek Play Fair in Canadian Win?
You can see Nemechek has taken a hard left to finish pushing Custer off the track.


NASCAR withheld their ruling on who won the race for a few minutes after the two trucks crossed the Start-Finish line. Custer was mad, as well he should have been. Nemechek was on his way to the flag stand to grab his ill-gotten checkered flag after the race. You can see him stop, turn and begin to run away. Then you see Custer enter the frame and drop Nemechek hard.


Did Nemechek Play Fair in Canadian Win?
Custer rebounds off the outside wall/tire barrier and there’s Nemechek to keep Custer from getting back on the track.


What makes this incident even more difficult to believe is that that same day, Tony Stewart purposely turned Brian Scott into the inside wall during the race at the Southern 500 at Darlington Raceway on Sept. 4. Tony got loose early in the corner and almost slid sideways into Scott’s car. After recovering, Tony can be seen approaching the left rear quarter of Scott’s car and turning him. The result of this on-track incident was that Stewart and his crew chief were called to the NASCAR Hauler after the race. Stewart was asked during a post-race interview with NBCSN what happened. His response was two words and an evil smile: “He crashed.”


Did Nemechek Play Fair in Canadian Win?
You can see Nemechek cocked across the front end of Custer’s truck, ensuring that his truck will cross the finish line first.


To me, what we see here is NASCAR ruling on on-track incidents in two separate ways. John Hunter Nemechek is seen to purposely drive a faster competitor’s truck into the wall and then hold it there, and NASCAR gives him the win. Stewart turns a four lap down driver into the inside wall and he’s called to the Hauler after the race to explain his actions.


Did Nemechek Play Fair in Canadian Win?
Cole Custer shows his displeasure with John Hunter Nemechek after the race. I think that Nemechek will have the shorted championship run on record as a result of this incident-Custer is going to make sure that Nemechek isn’t able to advance to the next round.


What do you think? Was Nemechek right? Was it just “rubbin’,” or was it that he wanted to win so badly that he didn’t care about the safety of other drivers, fans, and officials at the track? Personally, I think Nemechek should not have been awarded the victory, and he should have been penalized for dangerous behavior. I also think that Brian Scott should have been called to the Hauler after the Darlington race to explain why he didn’t give a lead lap car more room to maneuver/pass when he himself was four laps down.

About Mike Aguilar 388 Articles
Mike's love of cars began in the early 1970's when his father started taking him to his Chevron service station. He's done pretty much everything in the automotive aftermarket from gas station island attendant, parts counter, mechanic, and new and used sales. Mike also has experience in the amateur ranks of many of racing's sanctioning bodies.

2 Comments on Did Nemechek Play Fair in Canadian Win?

  1. I lost all respect for NASCAR when they announced that Nemechek had won. Bumping, rubbing, and blocking are all fair moves. Holding your competitor against a wall all the way down the front straight, giving him no way to outmaneuver you is dirty racing and should be illegal. I stopped watching the truck series after this incident. I don’t even watch much of the rest of NASCAR anymore. The template cars, multi-million dollar teams, and overpaid teenagers aren’t what NASCAR was about in the old days. I would rather see a race at a Saturday night local track.

    • NASCAR has to evolve with the times, wouldn’t you say? I do agree that the big dollar teams make it much harder for smaller teams to compete, especially when the manufacturer demands that all teams share all data like Toyota does, and especially when that manufacturer has paid NASCAR $400 million.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


I agree to receive emails from RacingJunk.com. I understand that I can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy