2 things. There are site rules. In your "proof", and I am not doubting you, but I don't see smokin72 going by either Mark or Anthony. So, while I know you are 'sure' it is in fact the person, if you are wrong and RJ shuts them down by taking your word for it, you won't be the one held liable.
2nd site rule is it clearly states in the main page rules when you sign up, that you can NOT run adds like the ones you got 'booted' for.
Sadly, he is better at gaming the system than you are...