You guys are right she prob would smack me in the nuts if I dont keep it lol Thanks for all the replies
It just amazes how crappy craftsman stuff has got, I have this box in the garage but its older and looks nothing like this. She told me to take it back and exchange it without dents. When I went to the local sears yesterday that guy acted like he could care less and really didnt think I should bring it back. "sometimes things happen in shipping" hmm does that mean I need to have a dented up tool box instead of new I think not.
I'll let ya know how things go today as I am going there again with the box