Bad deal.
I noticed in the pictures that you can see the trunk is suspect looking. Why do people often times advertise a decent car there is no air cleaner in the pic???? "Less than 100 miles" but no air cleaner??? Really???
Beyond that, it is hard to say what is unfair without knowing what this guy wants to get out of the car. If he was asking 25K, I would agree he is smoking something. If he wanted to trade for a 5K car, that is a different story. I did not see a price on the car?
The 1/4's on top of each other would really bug me... sorry you had to go through that.