Damn - I fit part of this guy's decription. Use to live in Florissant and now live in O' Fallon, well really 2 min from O'Fallon and know many in the area....
If the a$$hat that ripped you has a 63 Vette then he is likely known in the Vette community. Pretty tight knit and I am sure he doesn't want a reputation with the local community - word travels fast... can't recall the local vette forum, but stay tuned asking a buddy and will post up the address.
Also the O'Fallon, MO police department is top notch, much like Florissant. They will be on this guy like flies on sh!t. Are you working with a Florissant detective or O' Fallon detective?
Before I stir up the local crowd about this guy.... how certain are you this is the guy and his latest message is just to throw you off his track? did you call the cell phone number he listed?
Seems a really close damn coincidence. Johnny Rocket and redrocket63.... hmmmmmmm
Also can the site admin trace the IP of GOLOUD and redrocket63? If the same then guilty - I know this can be done on message forums when someone gets banned and trys to rejoin under a diff name.