Racingjunk Forums

Racingjunk Forums (https://www.racingjunk.com/forums/index.php)
-   Engine Tech (https://www.racingjunk.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=9)
-   -   MILODON OIL PUMP.....what a joke. (https://www.racingjunk.com/forums/showthread.php?t=20898)

Tod74 05-23-2008 09:43 AM

MILODON OIL PUMP.....what a joke.
 
I just got my new MILODON oil pump from Jegs...costs twice what the melling does...I have a new Melling but everyone has me afraid of it . SO I ordered the Milodon cause they say they have billet gears and yada yada...well I got it today and open the box and inside I find a MELLING M77HV pump exactly like the 34 dollar POS that I already have...SAME CASTING NUMBERS SAME EVERYTHING...SAME FREAKIN' PUMP. :evil: ..EXCEPT IT was 87 dollars after shipping. I called Jegs who told me Melling makes the pumps for Milodon....Well DUH!!! I can see that Mr. Wizard :roll: ....so they give me Milodon's number and they tell me that they bought a "Couple Thousand" of them from Melling 5 or 6 years ago when they were "GOOD" and that they have billet gears and have been "GONE THROUGH AND OPENED UP AND EVERYTHING LIKE THAT" those were his words. :roll: I said "PFFFT."
This pump is going back so basically I just gave jegs about 20 bucks for shipping for nothing...what a crock. Is there any pump worth a hoot besides the 400 dollar gerators? If I wanted a M77HV I would buy one for 34 bucks not 72 plus shipping.

promod45 05-23-2008 10:57 AM

pump
 
check out the cvr pump they sell a 4340 pump and a billet pump and they claim that they are billet gears

Tod74 05-23-2008 11:13 AM

Re: pump
 

Originally Posted by promod45
check out the cvr pump they sell a 4340 pump and a billet pump and they claim that they are billet gears

I can't find one. I can find the billet aluminum one but not the steel one. I emailed them and they said I could get one through competition products but all they list is the aluminum one

signsbyesa 05-23-2008 11:30 AM

i bought the CVR billet aluminum pump w/steel gears for $300.
you can give them a call their very helpful 1.800233.0199
just ordered a screen kit and stretch bolt gauge, good luck :wink:

jmarksdragster 05-23-2008 12:05 PM

Re: pump
 

Originally Posted by Tod74

Originally Posted by promod45
check out the cvr pump they sell a 4340 pump and a billet pump and they claim that they are billet gears

I can't find one. I can find the billet aluminum one but not the steel one. I emailed them and they said I could get one through competition products but all they list is the aluminum one

They are Billet Aluminum, NOT steel. The gears are billet steel. Competition Products is the place and although they don't list them, they have pickups for different depth pans.

promod45 05-23-2008 12:08 PM

pump
 
i have there catolge and they do have a 4340 pump you just need to call competion products and they can tell you, there pumps are very reasonable ..todd

promod45 05-23-2008 12:10 PM

pump
 
jmarksdragster is right they do sell billet aluminum pumps and they look really nice but they also sell the pumps with 4340 steel bodies and billet gears ..good luck

bbchevy 05-23-2008 12:53 PM

Re: pump
 

Originally Posted by promod45
i have there catolge and they do have a 4340 pump you just need to call competion products and they can tell you, there pumps are very reasonable ..todd

Todd,
I have the Cataloge in My Hands,on Page 145 CVR Pro-Lube Oil Pumps,t6-6061 Billet Alu.Housing,with Steel Billet Gears!
Maybe your Book has 4340 Pumps???Mine DONT!
Later
G 8)

promod45 05-23-2008 02:06 PM

pumps
 
marksdragster, im looking at the cvr catolge for 2008 and on page 25 of cvr they show a pic of a steel body pump made of 4340 part no op455 for a small block and they have billet gears, but the book i have only goes to page 27, that is what i have in my book but i could be wrong

edvancedengines 05-23-2008 02:14 PM

Or you could order a Titan through me for a litle more than the CVR Spur Gear Pump in the Billet Aluminum housing and get the real oil pump that is made to order to fit your pan depth and set to the bench pressure you ask for and is fully tested prior to shipping and is oily and wrapped in clear paper to keep the oil from leaking out. That is proof it is bench tested. Each one is tested. You get the pickup depth for what you need.

Only problem is some pans the Titan Pump will not fit because of the way the pan is made. Moroso on purpose tries to keep their pans from fitting but Titan has made slight changes to shape and can fit some of them.

Can not post the prices. Can respond back by email.
[email protected]

Ed

jmarksdragster 05-23-2008 02:56 PM

Must be new.

OneBadGMC 05-23-2008 07:08 PM

I bought a Sportsman Titan internal wet pump. My OLD Moroso pan didn't fit, and I had to cut out the corner and have it tig'd back together.

Aside for that hassle, I took the pump apart from curiosity. Simply the nicest oil pump I've ever had the pleasure of viewing.

curtisreed 05-23-2008 07:42 PM

http://www.cvrproducts.com/steel_oil_pumps.html

Tod74 05-23-2008 08:43 PM


Originally Posted by doorracer
http://www.cvrproducts.com/steel_oil_pumps.html

I know...that is the one I wanted...they told me comp products could sell me one but they only list the billet aluminum one. :(

Any opinions as to whether this milodon pump is any different than a regular melling? sure looks exactly the same and yes I took the cover off and looked at it. I can't tell any difference.

cepx111 05-23-2008 10:18 PM

Not everybody has $300 to $400 to drop on a oil pump I feel your pain Todd74
Somebody could make a fortune making/selling billet gears for M77HV's
Hmmmmmm....

Tod74 05-24-2008 03:56 AM


Originally Posted by cepx111
Not everybody has $300 to $400 to drop on a oil pump I feel your pain Todd74
Somebody could make a fortune making/selling billet gears for M77HV's
Hmmmmmm....

depends how you look at it I suppose.....I have 10 grand in the motor, not a lot for many but for me it is, so why put a 35 dollar oil pump on it? But you are right I am ready to put this thing back in and I don't have 400 bucks extra at the moment.

jmarksdragster 05-24-2008 06:49 AM


Originally Posted by Tod74

Originally Posted by doorracer
http://www.cvrproducts.com/steel_oil_pumps.html

Any opinions as to whether this milodon pump is any different than a regular melling? sure looks exactly the same and yes I took the cover off and looked at it. I can't tell any difference.

They buy them from Melling. At least get the CVR, but Titan is your best choice.

promod45 05-24-2008 08:09 AM

pump
 
I agree with jmarksdragster, the cvr pump from competion products is only 195.00 for there 4340 pump, atleast that is the price they gave me over the phone but i could be wrong ..before you buy just click on the sight below and then make your choice.....Posted: Sat May 24, 2008 3:42 am Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

http://www.cvrproducts.com/steel_oil_pumps.html

Tod74 05-24-2008 10:12 PM

Re: pump
 

Originally Posted by bbchevy

Originally Posted by promod45
i have there catolge and they do have a 4340 pump you just need to call competion products and they can tell you, there pumps are very reasonable ..todd

Todd,
I have the Cataloge in My Hands,on Page 145 CVR Pro-Lube Oil Pumps,t6-6061 Billet Alu.Housing,with Steel Billet Gears!
Maybe your Book has 4340 Pumps???Mine DONT!
Later
G 8)

Mine either. I even poked the part number from CVR WEBSITE INTO THE SEARCH ENGINE ON cOMPETITION PRODUCTS site and it came up no results. I emailed CVR and asked where to get one they said comp products and some other place I never heard of.

jrthone 05-24-2008 11:02 PM

What was the part # of the Miloden pump you brought Tod74?

Tod74 05-25-2008 05:54 AM

18760

was for a BBC They (milodon) told me they haven't released their own bbc pump yet that melling was the only ones who made a casting for a long time. Their website is misleading..cause they have a big picture of their small block pump and the casting says Milodon...so I just assumed they made their own pumps. Not the big blocks.

jrthone 05-26-2008 01:00 AM

I cant find any info that says the miloden pump comes with billit gears for BBC. Well nothing under $100 anyway.Where did you find that info out?

Tod74 05-26-2008 07:16 AM


Originally Posted by jrthone
I cant find any info that says the miloden pump comes with billit gears for BBC. Well nothing under $100 anyway.Where did you find that info out?

THEY DON'T!! THEY ARE MELLING PUMPS.

I called Milodon THEY CLAIM they are billet gear Melling

jrthone 05-26-2008 11:38 AM

Well thats a pain in the arse cos i just brought one.

OneBadGMC 05-26-2008 12:48 PM


Originally Posted by cepx111
Not everybody has $300 to $400 to drop on a oil pump I feel your pain Todd74
Somebody could make a fortune making/selling billet gears for M77HV's
Hmmmmmm....

Ok, so you buy a 40.00 oil pump, then spend 100.00 in billet gears?

Don't know about you, but I put new pumps on my motor every time I put new bearings in it. Cheap insurance.

I figure over the years, I've spent about 1k in oil pumps (at around 100.00 a shot).

So now, instead of continuing, I bucked up and bought a 400.00 pump that I can send back to Titan for freshening at the end of every season. It's more expensive up front, but it's cheaper in the long run.

Tod74 05-26-2008 09:13 PM


Originally Posted by jrthone
Well thats a pain in the arse cos i just brought one.

I laid mine on the bench next to the new melling I have and I could tell absolutely no difference. I even took the cover off and there was no evidence anything had been modified. It says M77HV on it too. They claimed it was the older one but I have an old melling from 2000-2001 and the casting is different. I can't just use it cause it sat outside in a junk barrel for awhile and obviously is no good anymore. Solid rust

us7race 05-27-2008 03:45 AM

I put in a Melling M-Select Oil pump it was $62 I think and has a bolt on pickup and seems to be alot better piece than the regular ones. It is a 70Lb pump with 10% more volume. The part number is 10552..

Here is the link...

http://data.melling.com/Select/small_block_chevy.php

jmarksdragster 05-27-2008 06:13 AM

They all have PM gears, Melling, Moroso, Milodon, including the Melling Select pumps. CVR and Titan pumps are the only ones currently using steel gears, except Moroso's gerotor pump. They all buy from Melling except for CVR and Titan. Don't waste your money.

Tod74 05-27-2008 09:59 AM


Originally Posted by jmarksdragster
They all have PM gears, Melling, Moroso, Milodon, including the Melling Select pumps. CVR and Titan pumps are the only ones currently using steel gears, except Moroso's gerotor pump. They all buy from Melling except for CVR and Titan. Don't waste your money.

MILODON makes their own pump for small blocks, just not big blocks...well, At least the sm blocks have Milodon cast into the housing anyway..don't know who makes em.

dcarr511 05-28-2008 07:31 AM

I dont like the idea of Powdered metal gears at all myself .. but have to ask ... If they make Connecting Rods that way, why wouldnt an oil pump gear work out ?

I have heard about and seen the newer main bodies crack or break. But I havent heard or seen anything about the gears breaking.

Has anyone else seen / heard differantly ?

Tod74 05-28-2008 10:03 AM


Originally Posted by dcarr511
I dont like the idea of Powdered metal gears at all myself .. but have to ask ... If they make Connecting Rods that way, why wouldnt an oil pump gear work out ?

I have heard about and seen the newer main bodies crack or break. But I havent heard or seen anything about the gears breaking.

Has anyone else seen / heard differantly ?

Yeah on speedtalk just the other day a circle track guy said after 7 laps the corner of the gear broke off and locked up his pump.

http://speedtalk.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=11089

dcarr511 05-28-2008 05:42 PM


Originally Posted by Tod74

Originally Posted by dcarr511
I dont like the idea of Powdered metal gears at all myself .. but have to ask ... If they make Connecting Rods that way, why wouldnt an oil pump gear work out ?

I have heard about and seen the newer main bodies crack or break. But I havent heard or seen anything about the gears breaking.

Has anyone else seen / heard differantly ?

Yeah on speedtalk just the other day a circle track guy said after 7 laps the corner of the gear broke off and locked up his pump.

http://speedtalk.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=11089

What a coincidence ... Ed Nix is a local engine builder here. He did some machine work for me on 1 block 14 yrs. ago or so. And " revolunationary " is close by also and is a level or two above Ed


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 01:46 PM.